To evaluate an AI ad generator, give every tool the same brief and score the results on ten points: whether it reads your brand correctly, handles your logo, lets you steer the layout, gets the words on the image right, delivers usable sizes, avoids inventing claims, writes varied copy, costs a reasonable amount per usable result, prices itself clearly, and is honest about what it does not do. Score each point from 0 to 2, add them up, and compare the totals alongside your own notes.
Demos show a tool at its best. This test shows you how it behaves on your product, with your logo, under your constraints. Plan an hour or two per tool.
Set up a fair test
Before you open any tool, write one brief and use it everywhere.
| Brief item | What to prepare |
|---|---|
| Website | Your real site, not a demo brand |
| Product | One product or service you actually sell. A software product or a service works as well as a physical item |
| Audience | One sentence on who it is for |
| Angle | One sentence on why they should care |
| Offer | Either a real offer or deliberately none |
| Placements | Where the ad will run (for example Instagram Feed and Stories) |
| Constraints | Brand colors, words you never use, claims you cannot make |
Two traps to avoid.
- Do not change the brief between tools. A better prompt for the tool you like turns the test into a sales demo.
- Leave one detail out on purpose. Do not give a price or discount in the brief. Whether a tool invents one tells you a lot.
The ten points
Score each point 0 (fails), 1 (acceptable with effort), or 2 (works well).
1. Brand accuracy
Test: Give the tool your website address and read the brand profile it builds. Check the name, tagline, colors, audience, and what you sell. Good looks like: It reads your business correctly, shows you what it found, and lets you correct it. Red flag: It guesses silently and you only find out from the output.
2. Logo handling
Test: Generate three images and look closely at the logo in each. Good looks like: Your actual logo, placed cleanly and left unaltered. Red flag: A redrawn, distorted, or invented mark. Generated logos often look right at a glance and wrong up close.
3. Layout control
Test: Try to get a specific composition: product on the left, headline top right, plenty of empty space. Good looks like: You can steer the layout through a reference, a template, or clear controls. Red flag: Layout is random, so every image is a lottery.
4. Text on the image
Test: Ask for a short headline and read every letter. Then ask for two lines. Good looks like: Correct spelling, legible type, and sensible placement. Red flag: Misspelled or garbled words. Any word on the image is a claim, so errors cost you a rerun.
5. Size and format
Test: Download the file and check its pixel dimensions and ratio against the placements you plan to use. Meta's Ads Guide lists 4:5 for Feed and 9:16 for Stories and Reels. Good looks like: Sizes match your placements, or the tool tells you how to adapt them. Red flag: Fixed output that needs heavy cropping, with no warning.
6. Claim discipline
Test: Leave the price out of your brief and see whether the copy or image supplies one. Ask for "social proof" and see what appears. Good looks like: The tool is designed not to invent statistics, reviews, ratings, prices, or guarantees, and it flags what you need to verify. No tool is perfect at this, so run the test several times and keep checking every claim yourself. Red flag: Confident numbers and testimonials you never provided. These become your legal problem.
7. Copy quality and variety
Test: Ask for five headlines on one angle and compare them. Good looks like: Five genuinely different lines. Red flag: Five rewordings of the same sentence, or stock phrases that could sit on any competitor's ad.
8. Cost per keeper
Test: Generate ten images and count how many you would actually run. Divide total cost by that number. Good looks like: A cost per usable image that fits your budget, with a clear price before each run. Red flag: A low advertised price and a keeper rate so poor that your real cost is several times higher.
9. Pricing clarity
Test: Find, without contacting sales, what a run costs, what happens to unused balance, how to cancel, and what the refund policy says. Good looks like: Costs shown before you commit, plain terms, and no surprise at renewal. Red flag: Usage caps that reset, credits that expire without notice, or a cancellation path you cannot find.
10. Scope and honesty
Test: Read the "about" and "terms" pages. Ask what the tool does not do. Good looks like: A clear statement of limits, such as no video or no publishing, so you know what else to budget for. Red flag: A feature list that implies it does everything.
A scoring sheet
Copy this table into a spreadsheet. Add one column per tool.
| # | Point | Tool A | Tool B | Tool C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brand accuracy | |||
| 2 | Logo handling | |||
| 3 | Layout control | |||
| 4 | Text on the image | |||
| 5 | Size and format | |||
| 6 | Claim discipline | |||
| 7 | Copy quality and variety | |||
| 8 | Cost per keeper | |||
| 9 | Pricing clarity | |||
| 10 | Scope and honesty | |||
| Total (out of 20) |
Do not average blindly. A zero on claim discipline or logo handling is a reason to rule a tool out, whatever its total.
How to read the totals
| Total | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| 16 to 20 | Strong fit. Run a small paid campaign to confirm |
| 11 to 15 | Usable, with known weak spots. Decide if you can live with them |
| 10 or below | Keep looking |
Weight the points by your situation. A brand with strict logo rules should treat point 2 as critical. A team running ads in several languages should add a point for language support. An agency should add one for managing several brands.
Questions to ask before you pay
- What does one run cost, and is that shown before I confirm?
- What happens to unused balance or credits?
- How do I get a refund if a run fails?
- What data from my site, my uploads, or my pasted text do you store, and for how long? (Do not accept a vague answer if you handle client or customer data.)
- What can I not do with this tool?
A vendor that answers these in writing is easier to trust than one that routes them to a call.
Where HeyUGC stands on its own list
A guide like this should apply to us as well. Here is a read against the ten points, based on how the app works today. Treat it as a description to test, not a result.
| Point | HeyUGC |
|---|---|
| Brand accuracy | Reads your site into an editable profile: name, category, tagline, audience, what you sell, colors, tone, and language. What you save wins over what it found. Photos and the logo are shown but not edited on the setup screens |
| Logo handling | Places your original logo onto the finished image rather than redrawing it. If there is no logo on file, or it cannot be placed, the result screen says so |
| Layout control | Layout and style follow the reference you choose from the catalogue or upload. The reference is analysed and described to the image model, not passed to it as an image |
| Text on the image | The brief lists the text that must appear, and any figure not in your profile needs your approval. An automatic review flags missing or misspelled text. The review can be wrong, so check every word yourself |
| Size and format | A PNG whose shape follows the reference (portrait, square, or landscape). The delivered size can differ from the size requested, so check dimensions against your placements |
| Claim discipline | The copy and script tools are instructed not to invent statistics, reviews, ratings, prices, or guarantees, and they return cautions. That is not a guarantee, so verification stays with you |
| Copy quality and variety | Five headlines per ad copy run, written to take different lines on one angle. Check that they really differ |
| Cost per keeper | 40 credits per image. Your rerun ratio sets your real cost |
| Pricing clarity | Pay-as-you-go credits, no subscription, and the pricing page says credits never expire. The copy tools show their price before you run them |
| Scope and honesty | Static images and three copy tools only |
The limits are worth stating plainly.
- HeyUGC does not make video, voiceovers, or avatars.
- It does not schedule or publish ads and posts.
- The image tool uses your brand profile. The copy tools take their own short brief and do not.
- Ad copy headlines run up to 40 characters, which is above the 27 characters Meta recommends for Facebook Feed.
- Credits for purchased top-ups are governed by the refund policy, which you should read before a large purchase.
If your workflow needs any of those things, test tools that offer them. For the cost side, see what an AI-generated ad image costs in credits.
Frequently asked questions
How many tools should I test?
Two or three. More than that and the comparison becomes a project of its own.
Should I pay for the test?
Use free trials and small top-ups where you can. A paid run on your own product is worth more than a demo.
What matters most when comparing AI ad generators?
Claim discipline and logo handling are the two failures that cost the most to fix after the ad is live. Weight them above style.
Can I judge a tool from its example gallery?
A gallery shows the best outputs. Your own brief shows the typical ones.
How do I compare subscription and credit pricing?
Reduce both to cost per usable image: total spend divided by the images you would actually run.
Run the test on your own site
Write the brief, pick two or three tools, and score them side by side. If HeyUGC is one of them, start at the homepage, add your website, and look at the brand profile before you spend a credit.



